Will the FTC allow RJR and BAT to merge or will there be a lawsuit to
block the proposed merger?
Vol. 1, No. 3 Jan. 22, 2004
Merger Documents filed
with SEC
The filings necessary to secure regulatory and other
approvals required to complete the merger of R.J. Reynolds Tobacco and
Brown & Williamson continue on schedule.
On Friday,
Jan. 16, Form S-4, a regulatory filing outlining the merger agreement
between RJR and BAT to combine their U.S. tobacco operations, was filed
with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The S-4 is the
"registration" document required by the SEC for all proposed mergers
that involve the issuance of stock in a public company. The filing
includes pro forma financial measures of the two companies, information
about the anticipated synergies the merger is expected to yield, and
extensive background on the U.S. tobacco industry. The SEC has one
month to review the S-4 and provide the companies any comments the
agency has on the document. Once the 2003
financial statements for both companies are finalized and audited,
they will be included in the S-4 through an amended filing.
A document similar to the final S-4 will be sent to RJR
shareholders later this spring as part of the solicitation of their
approval of the proposed merger. It is not certain at this time
whether the special shareholder meeting to approve the proposed merger
will be held in addition to or instead of RJR's regular annual
shareholder meeting now scheduled for May 5.
Both RJR and B&W
also continue to provide information to the Federal Trade Commission for
their analysis of the proposed merger. As was expected, the FTC
requested additional documents from both companies, and we are complying
with those requests.
October 29,
2003 12:53 a.m. EST
Tobacco Merger To Give Top Job To Susan
Ivey
By VANESSA O'CONNELL and DEBORAH BALL
Staff Reporters of
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Since before the days when "LSMFT" (or
Lucky Strike Means Fine Tobacco) was a famous ad slogan, Brown &
Williamson Tobacco Corp., which also markets Kool and Pall Mall, has
been a well-known name. But as a result of Monday's announcement that
R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Holdings will acquire Brown & Williamson, the
name will effectively be retired and the company subsumed into a new
entity, Reynolds American Inc. B&W's headquarters in Louisville,
Ky., will also be shut down.
But Brown & Williamson will live
on in the person of 44-year-old Susan Ivey, who will become chief
executive of the merged companies. And if the management plan stays on
track, six months later, when RJR's Andrew Schindler moves from
executive chairman to nonexecutive chairman, she will become the leader
of the second-largest tobacco company in the U.S.
Ms. Ivey will
be entering the hard-charging culture of RJR, whose shareholders will
initially own 58% of Reynolds American. British American Tobacco PLC,
B&W's parent since 1927, will own the rest. "I am excited about the
deal because I really do think . . . the new company has the potential
to be stronger than either of us individually," Ms. Ivey said in an
interview Tuesday.
In recent years, RJR has remained fiercely
unrepentant as cigarette makers have come under fire. Brown &
Williamson, by contrast, claims to have been the first tobacco company
to publicly acknowledge the dangers of smoking, on its Web site in 1997.
Meanwhile, Altria Group Inc.'s Philip Morris USA has taken the lead in
trying to find common ground with antismoking advocates, and the maker
of Marlboros now dominates the U.S. market. RJR and B&W came
together not just to fight the many outside threats to the tobacco
industry -- including litigation, high taxes and smoking bans -- but
also to stand up to Philip Morris on the one hand and deep-discount
competitors on the other.
"The two companies seem to have
significant cultural differences," says Blake Brown, professor of
agricultural economics at North Carolina State University. "British
American Tobacco is an international company that's known as fairly
progressive. RJR has endured a series of difficult mergers and spinoffs,
after which it decided to focus on the U.S."
The executive
entrusted with bringing off this union is one of a handful of women to
rise to the top in an especially male-oriented business. After
graduating from the University of Florida, Ms. Ivey moved to Louisville
and started working at an office-equipment company, taking
business-school classes at night and on weekends. She wanted to go into
sales and considered three areas: cigarettes (she smokes ultra-light
menthols), alcohol (wine and champagne) and cosmetics. "I said to
myself, 'I would like to do something I like,' " she says.
In
1981, Brown & Williamson had just launched its Barclay menthol
brand. Ms. Ivey liked the cigarettes, but when she went to a store to
buy more, they were out of stock. She called the company to inform them
of the distribution blunder. Within a week she had a job there, she
says.
Ms. Ivey rose through the ranks in sales and marketing,
first at Brown & Williamson, then at its London-based parent. From
1994 to 1996, she was based in Hong Kong as director of marketing for
China, then relocated to London as the head of British American
Tobacco's international brands. She engineered the relaunch of some key
brands, such as Lucky Strike in the European markets, and State Express
555 for the Asia-Pacific region. She changed packaging, marketing and
price points, which helped push up product market share. In 2000 she
returned to Louisville as a senior marketing executive. And by January
2001, she was Brown & Williamson's president and chief
executive.
The company's market share was slipping, to 10.6%
today from 15% in 1998, but Ms. Ivey slowed the attrition. The large
tobacco lawsuit settlement with state attorneys general that year
prompted the major tobacco companies to raise their prices while forcing
them to abide by new marketing restrictions. Ms. Ivey responded by
slashing the marketing budget of GPC, a discount brand, reasoning that
it couldn't compete with a new breed of deep-discount brands.
She
then oversaw the switch to an "everyday low-price" strategy for GPC and
Viceroy to undercut competitors' premium brands and cut down on costly
rebates and incentives. "The company's sales force would be able to hit
10 stores a day rather than five stores a day," because they didn't have
to waste time figuring out the retailer discount, she says. In early
2001, she successfully relaunched Pall Mall filtered cigarettes in the
U.S.
Ms. Ivey spent much of Tuesday meeting with employees in
Louisville, where job cuts are expected. The two companies aim to save
at least $500 million annually. "Certainly as we integrate these
companies there will be layoffs," she says. The current plan is to close
Brown & Williamson's only manufacturing plant, in Macon,
Ga.
Headquarters will be relocated to Winston-Salem. Ms. Ivey
says she's never been
there.